"Brainfreeze" was a Squirt Frog and the Evolving Tadpoles song written by Rob Ferguson. After a while, the band grew tired of the song (including Rob) and stopped playing it. A couple years later, while performing in New York, three people in different areas of the audience called for "Brainfreeze" despite it never being recorded or released by the band. Justin Nachman replied they weren't taking requests. The band continued with their playlist and signaled the sound man to up the volume when the audience persisted in shouting requests.